Géopolitique

Cette page regroupe l'ensemble des publications de Futuribles sur cette thématique (Vigie, revue, bibliographie, études, etc.)

Forum

Géopolitique

Europe : vive le déclin !

While not hiding his nostalgia for a federal Europe which might have been capable of establishing itself as a superpower on a par with the United States, Jean-Jacques Salomon argues in this deliberately provocative piece that Europe could become a confederation with a different cultural agenda.
Europe is indeed divided, he says, and incapable of federating, of making itself a superpower and of developing the same ambitions vis-à-vis the world and same strategic postures as the United States. So much the worse for the god of war.
But perhaps instead, since it can't turn into an empire, Europe could create a confederation and make sufficient progress in cultural terms to be the Greece of modern times.

Revue

Géopolitique - Institutions

Les institutions européennes dans l’impasse

Everyone is aware that the institutions of the EU are facing the problem of a lack of effectiveness and legitimacy which threatens to worsen as the number of member states increases (to 20, 25, 30 or even more). Will the latest intergovernmental conference to be held in Nice in December 2000 manage to find a solution to current problems, which are the same as those that its predecessor failed to resolve in 1997 in the Amsterdam Treaty?
Yves Bertoncini argues here that there are two main issues at stake: (i) the composition and work of the European Commission, and (ii) the decision-making process in the Council of Ministers. He thinks that there may be a solution which will offer an escape from the never-ending debate about the way that decisions are reached by resorting to the procedure known as "reinforced co-operations".
The author highlights first the ambiguous situation of the Commission arising from uncertainty about the status of the Commissioners -are they each representatives of their nation or do they together make up a supranational, collegial administrative body?- which then affects how many there are (the need for every member state to be represented) and their weight in the decision-making process. He points out the anomalies relating to the Commission's powers, in particular with regard to legislation, when it is not sufficiently independent of the member states; he therefore proposes ways in which reforms might increase the Commission's effectiveness and legitimacy.
In the next section, Bertoncini looks at the system of voting in the Council of Ministers and argues that it is essential to abandon the principle of unanimity, which is a major source of bottlenecks, and to discuss the current decision-making procedures and their attendant problems, given the weight of each member state and the size of majority required in each case. He shows how complicated the present system is and discusses the various solutions being considered, with the difficulties they raise.
Finally, looking forward to the possibility that the latest negotiations on this matter will fail once again, Yves Bertoncini proposes, more pragmatically, even greater use of the system of "reinforced co-operations", which would have the advantage that "it does not a priori exclude any member state but does take account of the extremely variable positions of different countries in a union with 20 or 30 members, in which it would be utterly futile to try to get them all to keep in step". In doing so, Bertoncini pleads that, as long as no entirely satisfactory overall institutional arrangements can be achieved, at least de facto shifting alliances should be allowed to develop.

Revue

Géopolitique

Le retour de la guerre des étoiles

Ten years after the end of the Cold War, Pierre Bonnaure remarks, Bill Clinton decided to revive the notion of an anti-missile defence system for the United States, because he is anxious to reassure public opinion about the possible threats from "rogue states". Admittedly, as his term comes to an end, the American President has just put off a decision until later, but the question remains open.
Bringing up to date the strategy of nuclear deterrence and reviewing the various treaties that lay down the rules of the game carries the risk of destabilising the parties concerned, whether nor not they signed the treaties, as well as of having unwanted side-effects: abuse of power, strengthening nuclear weapons programmes, revival of the arms race, challenging traditional alliances and the role of NATO, not to mention potential nuclear catastrophe.
To create a new system of protection and deterrence to shelter just the United States, or perhaps its allies as well, means once again putting into question the policies on defence and on nuclear non-proliferation, with the risk of driving Russia to adopt a rigid stance and to undermine the fragile balance of global security.
How can we stop the proliferation and use of weapons of mass destruction? That is the weighty question that Bill Clinton is leaving for his successor to answer.

Revue

Économie, emploi - Géopolitique - Institutions

La transition indienne

Jean-Luc Racine sets out here a masterly account of the current transition in India, a transition that he argues will allow this enormous country, with over a billion inhabitants, to overcome its internal contradictions and become a major player in tomorrow's world.
This important transition is taking place first of all at the domestic, political level through the decline of the Congress Party and the rise of the Bharat People's Party (BJP) which champions the Hindu nationalism in spite of the increase in the number of regionalist parties.
The economic element of the transition has taken the form of a two-stage programme of limited but continuous moves towards liberalisation. This policy has required major structural reforms, but these have been carried out cautiously, with a view to re-establishing the main equilibria, and ensuring high levels of economic growth, which will be judged in the end by its capacity to promote more equitable human development.
In the second half of the article, devoted to India's foreign policy, Jean-Luc Racine first describes the policy adopted to make the country a nuclear power, and then shows how this affects India's handling of its geopolitical relations with its neighbours, especially its tense and ambiguous interactions with Pakistan and China. Lastly, he examines how New Delhi is trying to establish itself as one of the main players on the world scene while at the same time maintaining a completely new style of dialogue with Washington.
The portrait of India sketched by Jean-Luc Racine is of a giant who is gradually waking up, of a country that, stifling its internal tensions and inequalities, is at the stage of rapid take-off and is preparing to play a major role in the world of the future.

Revue

Entreprises, travail - Géopolitique

L’intelligence stratégique : propos d’un analyste. Le métier du renseignement

Colonel Baud, who currently works at the Swiss army's headquarters in Berne, was employed for more than seven years as an analyst by the Swiss intelligence service. He has compiled two encyclopaedias, one on intelligence-gathering and secret services (Paris: Lavauzelle, 1997) and another on terrorism (Encyclopédie du terrorisme. Paris: Lavauzelle, 1999), and he agreed to be interviewed for Futuribles by Jérôme Marchand.
He talks first about intelligence as a profession - which in many ways covers the same field as strategic surveillance - and the special skills required for the job, in particular in terms of intellectual curiosity (and therefore openness of mind), the ability to distance oneself from events (and therefore good judgement), as well as the ability to anticipate what might happen.
Colonel Baud then offers a rapid critical survey of the bodies responsible for intelligence, where their strengths and weaknesses lie, especially in the radically different geopolitical context following the end of the Cold War.
The main topic of the last part of the interview is the new threats that are typical of today's world, which are quite unlike those of the past because the issues of internal and external security, both civilian and military, are increasingly interconnected.

Bibliography

Géopolitique

« Contrôler l’effet de serre : l’enjeu de politique publique internationale »

Ce numéro de la revue Économie internationale fait le point sur les enjeux de la gestion de l'effet de serre en termes de politique publique internationale. La plupart des spécialistes français de la question nous livrent donc l'état de leurs recherches économiques en la matière. Olivier Godard relate ainsi l'expérience américaine des permis négociables, d'abord de 1977 à 1989, montrant les formules expérimentées et les raisons de certains échecs ; ensuite à partir de 1990 et du ...

(206 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique - Territoires, réseaux

« Territoires 2020 »

La Datar lance une nouvelle revue qui se veut une tribune d'idées nouvelles et un lieu de réflexion sur le devenir de l'aménagement du territoire en France et en Europe. Territoires 2020 reprend le fil des ambitions qui avaient présidé à la naissance de la revue 2000 à la fin des années 1960 - une relecture rétrospective très intéressante de cette première expérience (qui a duré jusqu'en 1978) est d'ailleurs proposée dans ce numéro. On y trouvera ...

(153 more words)

Revue

Géopolitique

Prospective européenne : leçons d’histoire

"The more our society denies the past, the more it is influenced by it" argues Pierre Béhar in the preface to his most recent book, Vestiges d'empires (Remnants of empire, Paris: Desjonquères, 1999). Bernard Cazes therefore went to interview him about the process of collapse in Central Europe and the Balkans and, beyond that, about social trends over the very long term and impact of human decision-making, depending on whether these trends are taken into account or ignored.
The article is more about the past than the future. Pierre Béhar shares with us his thoughts on the construction and collapse of empires and states, in particular those created artificially, without regard to the past (as he stresses), at the end of the First World War - now history has reasserted itself. Basing his arguments on the history of the people of Europe across many centuries, he explains why certain frontiers remain stable, others are redrawn peaceably, while yet other states continue to tear each other apart in bloody conflicts.
Throughout the interview he emphasizes how important it is to recognize ethnic and national identities and how dangerous it is to construct artificial groupings, yet he also argues in favour of creating coherent political and strategic entities and picks out three that are vital in Europe. As might be expected, he is therefore extremely critical of the process of European unification - and even more so of the adoption of a common defence policy - which he feels is a case of "putting the cart before the horse", since agreements are sought about means before agreement has been reached about ends. Nevertheless, he recognizes the importance of having a common foreign policy vis-à-vis, in the first place, our Balkan neighbours.
A key question emerges from among the lessons of the historian for the futures studies specialist: what are the relative weights of historical determinism and of human freedom?

Bibliography

Économie, emploi - Géopolitique

« Transnational Trade Unionism : Facing the Challenges of Regionalisation and Globalisation »

La première livraison de l'année 2000 de la revue Transfer est entièrement consacrée au syndicalisme et à ses mutations dans le contexte actuel de mondialisation. Dans son article d'introduction, Otto Jacobi entend démontrer que la coopération syndicale internationale ne peut réussir qu'à condition que soient éliminées les tendances au protectionnisme et au dumping. Au niveau européen, remarque-t-il, la coopération syndicale doit faire face à de nombreux changements induits par la révolution économique en cours. Rebecca Gumbrell-McCormik parcourt ...

(212 more words)

Revue

Économie, emploi - Géopolitique

Décomposition, recomposition europénnes. Leçons du Kosovo

The disintegration of the Balkans is occurring just at the time when Western Europe, by contrast, is trying to form a union. This is reviving an old debate on the European continent for which, split as we are between respect for borders and recognition of nations, no satisfactory solution has yet been found. Certainly no answer is forthcoming for the Balkans, where the artificially created federal states did not survive the wish of the inhabitants to determine their own destiny, even if the price was bloody conflicts.
What solution can be proposed now to the problem of Kosovo, in order that its example should not spread, nor lead to the formation of many small, independent states, nor - conversely - equally artificial regional groupings, which will soon fall prey to the same tensions?
Elvire Letourneur-Fabry, went to interview Pierre Hassner about the possible ways of resolving the conflict and, more generally, about the rules of arbitration that might be adopted to deal with the problem of minorities. The celebrated professor of political science warns us against overly dogmatic notions that would encourage a systematic preference for national or supranational solutions.
As he analyses the situation in the Balkans, Pierre Hassner argues for a policy that would, if nothing else, prevent the conflicts from proliferating. More generally, he stresses the fragility of the compromises in Europe, and the difficulty that the European Union will have if it is to create for itself a genuine foreign policy and a common defence policy capable of imposing peace on its immediate neighbours.

Bibliography

Géopolitique

« Governi mondiali a macchia di leopardo e sovranità balcaniche » [Gouvernement mondial en peau de léopard et souveraineté balkanique]

Ce double numéro de la revue italienne Futuribili, publiée par l'Institut de sociologie de Gorizia, étudie les mutations que vit, depuis la chute du mur de Berlin, la scène des relations internationales, à travers les nouvelles fonctions et légitimités échues aux organisations internationales, qu'elles soient régionales (Union européenne ou Organisation du traité de l'Atlantique Nord) ou mondiales (Organisation des Nations unies). Suite à la disparition de l'une des deux superpuissances, les organisations internationales ont été amenées ...

(265 more words)

Bibliography

Économie, emploi - Géopolitique

Le FMI, de l’ordre monétaire aux désordres financiers

Incontournable ! Oui, ce livre est incontournable par l'actualité des questions abordées, la pertinence des solutions proposées ou, sur certains points, seulement esquissées, la fermeté et la clarté des propos. L'histoire sert à prendre la mesure des changements structurels intervenus (la globalisation financière bien sûr, mais aussi l'intégration européenne, l'affirmation sur la scène politique et financière des pays émergents...), comme elle permet de saisir le poids respectif des discontinuités et des inerties. Michel Aglietta et Sandra Moatti ...

(871 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

Jihad : expansion et déclin de l’islamisme

Le dernier quart du XXe siècle a été marqué par l'émergence, l'ascension puis le déclin des mouvements islamistes. Si l'islamisme est un courant qui puise ses racines à la fin du XIXe siècle, Gilles Kepel postule dans son ouvrage l'autonomie de la séquence des 30 dernières années parce que la référence à l'islamisme y apparaît « comme une nouvelle utopie, un idéal politique qui s'est très largement substitué à l'idéal nationaliste qui prévalait depuis ...

(378 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

Global Trends 2015 : A Dialogue about the Future with Non-Government Experts

Comme l'indique le titre de ce rapport, la CIA (Central Intelligence Agency) a compris que le temps du secret obsessionnel était révolu. Les estimations prospectives produites en milieu clos, sur la base de sources « grises » et « noires », se sont à de multiples reprises révélées décalées. Ce fut le cas, par exemple, des rapports relatifs à la puissance économique de l'URSS postbrejnevienne. Or il faut dire ici que les demandes des décideurs politico-administratifs ont fortement évolué depuis le début ...

(792 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

The Quest for Identity. International Relations of Southeast Asia

Dans cet ouvrage, Amitav Acharya, spécialiste des questions de sécurité régionale et des relations internationales en Asie du Sud-Est, cherche à rompre avec une propension des historiens à se focaliser sur l'un ou l'autre des pays de l'Asie du Sud-Est sans construire la région en tant que telle comme objet d'étude à part entière. Certes, nombreux sont les travaux qui envisagent la dimension régionale pour aborder les problèmes économiques ou de sécurité mais l'auteur situe ...

(401 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique - Territoires, réseaux

Le Viêt-Nam face à l’avenir

L'ouvrage écrit par Philippe Delalande au terme d'un séjour prolongé au Viêt-Nam est attractif à double titre : il dresse un état des lieux et pose des questions qui intéressent directement les décideurs qui ont à traiter avec ce pays, porteur de clichés tenaces en France mais aussi de promesses. C'est dire l'ambition affichée de l'auteur et le niveau d'attente du lecteur. Au bilan positif de l'entreprise, il faut citer la facilité de lecture ...

(217 more words)

Bibliography

Économie, emploi - Géopolitique

Interpreting China’s Grand Strategy : Past, Present and Future

Cet ouvrage, réalisé par la Rand pour alimenter la stratégie de défense aérienne américaine, entend comprendre et répondre le plus efficacement possible à l'essor de la puissance chinoise. Car si la Chine a toujours été un élément important dans le système international (par la taille de sa population et de son territoire, ses ressources...), son poids n'a cessé de croître depuis 1978 et l'entrée de ce pays dans « l'économie de marché ». La « grande stratégie » chinoise, n ...

(353 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

Les Enjeux du XXIe siècle. Entretien avec Antonio Polito

L'historien de renom Éric Hobsbawm, à la suite de son ouvrage tardivement paru en France L'âge des extrêmes, s'efforce au cours de cet entretien de dégager les grandes tendances du siècle qui s'ouvre. Conscient que le passé exerce un poids sur l'avenir, mais sans pourtant prétendre le prédire, il s'interroge sur les continuités probables qui se dégageront entre le siècle qui s'achève (un siècle de conflits) et celui qui commence, et anticipe l ...

(460 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

La Russie inachevée

Le retard russe résulterait de la nature spécifique des Russes et d'une histoire singulière liée à un caractère national et à une fatalité qui feraient échapper ce peuple et ce pays aux convergences de la mondialisation. Cette hypothèse, à la mode au XIXe siècle et de nouveau en vogue à l'aube du XXIème, est le fil conducteur du questionnement théorique de cet ouvrage, écrit par l'une des plus grandes spécialistes de l'histoire de la Russie, l ...

(212 more words)

Bibliography

Géopolitique

Losing Control : Global Security in the Twenty-First Century

Depuis la fin de la guerre froide, deux théories s'opposent sur la nature du système international. La majorité des spécialistes en stratégie estime que la guerre froide s'est terminée sur une victoire « nette et sans bavures » des États-Unis et de l'Alliance atlantique, et que ce sont les armes nucléaires qui ont maintenu la paix. L'économie de marché est désormais reconnue par tous comme la seule forme politique et économique rationnelle. Et, à ce jour, aucune puissance ...

(359 more words)

Chapitre Géopolitique

Ce chapitre est extrait du Rapport Vigie 2016 de Futuribles International, qui propose un panorama structuré des connaissances et des incertitudes des experts que l'association a mobilisés pour explorer les évolutions des 15 à 35 prochaines années sur 11 thématiques.